{"sources":["https:\/\/dip21.bundestag.de\/dip21\/btd\/19\/077\/1907777.pdf","https:\/\/dip21.bundestag.de\/dip21\/btd\/19\/077\/1907777.pdf, https:\/\/www.thalesgroup.com\/en\/markets\/digital-identity-and-security\/government\/inspired\/eid-in-germany, ","https:\/\/initiatived21.de\/egovernment-monitor\/","https:\/\/io.italia.it\/dashboard\/","https:\/\/www.bsi.bund.de\/DE\/Themen\/ZertifizierungundAnerkennung\/Produktzertifizierung\/ZertifizierungnachTR\/ZertifizierteProdukte\/eID-Clients\/eID-Clients.html?nn=6617968","https:\/\/www.de-mail.info","https:\/\/www.de-mail.info\/verzeichnis.html#page=16&typ=Firma","https:\/\/www.epaybl.de\/?ID=5&art_param=6;","https:\/\/www.epaykommunal.de\/;","https:\/\/www.paydirekt.de\/presse\/e-payment-in-der-oeffentlichen-verwaltung-paydirekt-gewinnt-erneut-egovernment-computing-award.html","https:\/\/www.itzbund.de\/DE\/itloesungen\/standardloesungen\/epayment\/epayment_node.html;jsessionid=0B650CBEA2FA6E0BA9D7C011F7AFF36A.internet961#bodyText1788781","https:\/\/www.paydirekt.de\/presse\/e-payment-in-der-oeffentlichen-verwaltung-paydirekt-gewinnt-erneut-egovernment-computing-award.html","https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/SiteGlobals\/Forms\/Webs\/PA\/suche\/anwendungensuche-formular.html","https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/SiteGlobals\/Forms\/Webs\/PA\/suche\/anwendungensuche-formular.html?gtp=14626016_list%253D3&cl2Categories_Anbieter=bundesland"],"summary":{"abbr":"DE","country_name":"Germany","summary":"<p><strong>eID <\/strong>In Germany, the<a href=\"https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/Webs\/PA-INFO\/Index.html\"> function for electronic identification<\/a> has been integrated into the mandatory national legal photo ID since 2010.&nbsp;<\/p>\n<p><strong>ePayment <\/strong>Among others, providers for ePayment services in the German public sector are <a href=\"https:\/\/www.paydirekt.de\/presse\/e-payment-in-der-oeffentlichen-verwaltung-paydirekt-gewinnt-erneut-egovernment-computing-award.html\">paydirekt<\/a> and <a href=\"https:\/\/www.epaybl.de\/?ID=80&amp;art_param=28\">ePayBL<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p><strong>Messaging <\/strong>The German government&rsquo;s digital mailing service <a href=\"https:\/\/www.de-mail.info\/verzeichnis.html#page=16\">De-Mail<\/a> is offered by public authorities and companies and provides a legally and secure way of communication. There is no government SMS service in place.<\/p>\n<p><strong>Transparency <\/strong>Germany currently has no measures in place to offer insights in personal ongoing affairs. This might change with the implementation of the so-called <a href=\"https:\/\/oeffentlicher-dienst-news.de\/digitale-verwaltung-steuer-identifikationsnummer\/\">Datencockpit<\/a>t in the near future.<\/p>\n<p><strong>General Digital Services <\/strong>The level of user satisfaction is measured by the <a href=\"https:\/\/initiatived21.de\/egovernment-monitor\/\">eGovernment Monitor<\/a> on a yearly basis. No systematic measurement of digital form submission has been found.<\/p>\n<p>The <em>Digital Government MetaMonitor<\/em> indicates a low level of quality of publicly available data on the German eID&rsquo;s uptake, more than ten years after its first implementation. The same applies to data in the categories General Digital Services, ePayment and Messaging.<\/p>"},"tables":{"eID":{"Overall uptake":[{"id":40,"year":2020,"id_indicator":1,"indicator":"Activated eID accounts (total)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1020,"subcategory":"Overall uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":67,"year":2020,"id_indicator":2,"indicator":"eID transactions (total)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1020,"subcategory":"Overall uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/dip21.bundestag.de\/dip21\/btd\/19\/077\/1907777.pdf","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":49,"year":2020,"id_indicator":3,"indicator":"eID app downloads","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1020,"subcategory":"Overall uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/dip21.bundestag.de\/dip21\/btd\/19\/077\/1907777.pdf","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":58,"year":2020,"id_indicator":4,"indicator":"eID app installations","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1020,"subcategory":"Overall uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":85,"year":2020,"id_indicator":5,"indicator":"eID-powered services (total)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1020,"subcategory":"Overall uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":133,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/SiteGlobals\/Forms\/Webs\/PA\/suche\/anwendungensuche-formular.html?gtp=14626016_list%253D3&cl2Categories_Anbieter=bundesland","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":76,"year":2020,"id_indicator":6,"indicator":"eID-powered organisations","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1020,"subcategory":"Overall uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":128,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/SiteGlobals\/Forms\/Webs\/PA\/suche\/anwendungensuche-formular.html","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}],"Personal uptake":[{"id":94,"year":2020,"id_indicator":7,"indicator":"Activated eID accounts (personal)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1030,"subcategory":"Personal uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":2,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":25000000,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/dip21.bundestag.de\/dip21\/btd\/19\/077\/1907777.pdf, https:\/\/www.thalesgroup.com\/en\/markets\/digital-identity-and-security\/government\/inspired\/eid-in-germany, ","last_update":"2019-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":112,"year":2020,"id_indicator":8,"indicator":"eID transactions (personal)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1030,"subcategory":"Personal uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":2,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":103,"year":2020,"id_indicator":9,"indicator":"Digital proxy registrations","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1030,"subcategory":"Personal uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":2,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}],"Business uptake":[{"id":4,"year":2020,"id_indicator":10,"indicator":"Activated eID accounts (business)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1010,"subcategory":"Business uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":3,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":13,"year":2020,"id_indicator":11,"indicator":"eID transactions (business)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1010,"subcategory":"Business uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":3,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":31,"year":2020,"id_indicator":12,"indicator":"eID-powered private services","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1010,"subcategory":"Business uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":3,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":29,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/SiteGlobals\/Forms\/Webs\/PA\/suche\/anwendungensuche-formular.html?gtp=14626016_list%253D3&cl2Categories_Anbieter=bundesland","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":22,"year":2020,"id_indicator":13,"indicator":"eID-powered private service providers","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1010,"subcategory":"Business uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":3,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":25,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.bsi.bund.de\/DE\/Themen\/ZertifizierungundAnerkennung\/Produktzertifizierung\/ZertifizierungnachTR\/ZertifizierteProdukte\/eID-Clients\/eID-Clients.html?nn=6617968","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}],"Public sector uptake":[{"id":184,"year":2020,"id_indicator":14,"indicator":"eID-powered public services","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":104,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/SiteGlobals\/Forms\/Webs\/PA\/suche\/anwendungensuche-formular.html","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":175,"year":2020,"id_indicator":15,"indicator":"eID-powered public service providers (total)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":86,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/SiteGlobals\/Forms\/Webs\/PA\/suche\/anwendungensuche-formular.html?gtp=14626016_list%253D3&cl2Categories_Anbieter=bundesland","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":148,"year":2020,"id_indicator":16,"indicator":"eID-powered central\/federal governments","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":13,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/SiteGlobals\/Forms\/Webs\/PA\/suche\/anwendungensuche-formular.html?gtp=14626016_list%253D3&cl2Categories_Anbieter=bundesland","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":193,"year":2020,"id_indicator":17,"indicator":"eID-powered regions","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":14,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/SiteGlobals\/Forms\/Webs\/PA\/suche\/anwendungensuche-formular.html?gtp=14626016_list%253D3&cl2Categories_Anbieter=bundesland","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":157,"year":2020,"id_indicator":18,"indicator":"eID-powered municipalities","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":59,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/SiteGlobals\/Forms\/Webs\/PA\/suche\/anwendungensuche-formular.html?gtp=14626016_list%253D3&cl2Categories_Anbieter=bundesland","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":166,"year":2020,"id_indicator":19,"indicator":"eID-powered other administrations","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.personalausweisportal.de\/SiteGlobals\/Forms\/Webs\/PA\/suche\/anwendungensuche-formular.html?gtp=14626016_list%253D3&cl2Categories_Anbieter=bundesland","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":139,"year":2020,"id_indicator":20,"indicator":"Digital proxy-powered services","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":130,"year":2020,"id_indicator":21,"indicator":"Digital proxy-powered organisations","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}],"Private sector support":[{"id":121,"year":2020,"id_indicator":22,"indicator":"eID providers","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":1040,"subcategory":"Private sector support","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":5,"id_main_category":1000,"main_category":"eID","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":3,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.bsi.bund.de\/DE\/Themen\/ZertifizierungundAnerkennung\/Produktzertifizierung\/ZertifizierungnachTR\/ZertifizierteProdukte\/eID-Clients\/eID-Clients.html?nn=6617968","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}]},"ePayment":{"Overall uptake":[{"id":211,"year":2020,"id_indicator":23,"indicator":"ePayment transactions","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":2020,"subcategory":"Overall uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":2000,"main_category":"ePayment","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":220,"year":2020,"id_indicator":24,"indicator":"ePayment value","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":2020,"subcategory":"Overall uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":2000,"main_category":"ePayment","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}],"Public sector uptake":[{"id":274,"year":2020,"id_indicator":27,"indicator":"ePayment-powered public service providers (total)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":2050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":2000,"main_category":"ePayment","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":13,"notes":"This number refers to the ePayment service ePayBL only. ","machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.itzbund.de\/DE\/itloesungen\/standardloesungen\/epayment\/epayment_node.html;jsessionid=0B650CBEA2FA6E0BA9D7C011F7AFF36A.internet961#bodyText1788781","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":247,"year":2020,"id_indicator":28,"indicator":"ePayment-powered central\/federal governments","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":2050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":2000,"main_category":"ePayment","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":283,"year":2020,"id_indicator":29,"indicator":"ePayment-powered regions","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":2050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":2000,"main_category":"ePayment","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":256,"year":2020,"id_indicator":30,"indicator":"ePayment-powered municipalities","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":2050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":2000,"main_category":"ePayment","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":650,"notes":"This number only refers to the 2019 data for one ePayment provider: Paydirekt: https:\/\/www.paydirekt.de\/presse\/e-payment-in-der-oeffentlichen-verwaltung-paydirekt-gewinnt-erneut-egovernment-computing-award.html","machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.paydirekt.de\/presse\/e-payment-in-der-oeffentlichen-verwaltung-paydirekt-gewinnt-erneut-egovernment-computing-award.html","last_update":"2019-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":265,"year":2020,"id_indicator":31,"indicator":"ePayment-powered other administrations","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":2050,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":2000,"main_category":"ePayment","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}],"Private sector support":[{"id":238,"year":2020,"id_indicator":32,"indicator":"ePayment providers","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":2040,"subcategory":"Private sector support","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":5,"id_main_category":2000,"main_category":"ePayment","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":3,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.epaybl.de\/?ID=5&art_param=6;\nhttps:\/\/www.epaykommunal.de\/;\nhttps:\/\/www.paydirekt.de\/presse\/e-payment-in-der-oeffentlichen-verwaltung-paydirekt-gewinnt-erneut-egovernment-computing-award.html","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}]},"Messaging":{"Overall uptake":[{"id":319,"year":2020,"id_indicator":33,"indicator":"Digital mail app downloads","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3020,"subcategory":"Overall uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":0,"existent":1,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/io.italia.it\/dashboard\/","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":328,"year":2020,"id_indicator":34,"indicator":"Digital mail app installations","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3020,"subcategory":"Overall uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":0,"existent":1,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}],"Personal uptake":[{"id":337,"year":2020,"id_indicator":35,"indicator":"Digital mail registrations (personal)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3030,"subcategory":"Personal uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":2,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":"\nIn a survey from 2016  among 1008 participants, 9% of German citizens said they plan to get a DE-Mail account, 45% said they do not plan to get an account (https:\/\/de.statista.com\/statistik\/daten\/studie\/612919\/umfrage\/nutzung-und-bekanntheit-von-de-mail\/).","machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":346,"year":2020,"id_indicator":36,"indicator":"Government SMS registrations (personal)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3030,"subcategory":"Personal uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":2,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":0,"existent":1,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}],"Business uptake":[{"id":310,"year":2020,"id_indicator":37,"indicator":"Digital mail registrations (business)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3010,"subcategory":"Business uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":3,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":152,"notes":"https:\/\/www.de-mail.info\/verzeichnis.html#page=16&typ=Firma","machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.de-mail.info\/verzeichnis.html#page=16&typ=Firma","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}],"Public sector uptake":[{"id":391,"year":2020,"id_indicator":38,"indicator":"Digital mail-powered organisations","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3040,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":191,"notes":"191 public organisations in total offer the DE-Mail service. https:\/\/www.de-mail.info\/verzeichnis.html#page=186&typ=Behoerde","machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.de-mail.info","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":373,"year":2020,"id_indicator":39,"indicator":"Digital mail-powered central\/federal governments","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3040,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.de-mail.info","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":409,"year":2020,"id_indicator":40,"indicator":"Digital mail-powered regions","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3040,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.de-mail.info","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":382,"year":2020,"id_indicator":41,"indicator":"Digital mail-powered municipalities","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3040,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.de-mail.info","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":400,"year":2020,"id_indicator":42,"indicator":"Digital mail-powered other administrations","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3040,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":"No","upfreq":null,"source":"https:\/\/www.de-mail.info","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":418,"year":2020,"id_indicator":43,"indicator":"Government SMS sent (personal)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3040,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":364,"year":2020,"id_indicator":44,"indicator":"Digital mail sent (personal)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3040,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":355,"year":2020,"id_indicator":45,"indicator":"Digital mail sent (business)","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":3040,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":4,"id_main_category":3000,"main_category":"Messaging","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}]},"Transparency":{"Public sector uptake":[{"id":445,"year":2020,"id_indicator":46,"indicator":"Myaffairs-powered organisations","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":4010,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":5,"id_main_category":4000,"main_category":"Transparency","country":"DE","relevant":0,"existent":1,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":427,"year":2020,"id_indicator":47,"indicator":"Myaffairs-powered central\/federal governments","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":4010,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":5,"id_main_category":4000,"main_category":"Transparency","country":"DE","relevant":0,"existent":1,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":463,"year":2020,"id_indicator":48,"indicator":"Myaffairs-powered regions","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":4010,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":5,"id_main_category":4000,"main_category":"Transparency","country":"DE","relevant":0,"existent":1,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":436,"year":2020,"id_indicator":49,"indicator":"Myaffairs-powered municipalities","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":4010,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":5,"id_main_category":4000,"main_category":"Transparency","country":"DE","relevant":0,"existent":1,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":454,"year":2020,"id_indicator":50,"indicator":"Myaffairs-powered other administrations","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":4010,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":5,"id_main_category":4000,"main_category":"Transparency","country":"DE","relevant":0,"existent":1,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":472,"year":2020,"id_indicator":51,"indicator":"Mydata availability","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":4010,"subcategory":"Public sector uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":5,"id_main_category":4000,"main_category":"Transparency","country":"DE","relevant":0,"existent":1,"val":null,"notes":"A service called \"datacockpit\" is being developed by the Init AG, but has not been launched yet: https:\/\/www.kommune21.de\/meldung_35119_Abschlussbericht+zum+Datencockpit.html","machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}]},"General Digital Services":{"Personal uptake":[{"id":292,"year":2020,"id_indicator":52,"indicator":"Digital form submission","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":5010,"subcategory":"Personal uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":5000,"main_category":"General Digital Services","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":0,"val":null,"notes":null,"machine_readable":null,"upfreq":null,"source":null,"last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1},{"id":301,"year":2020,"id_indicator":53,"indicator":"User satisfaction","visible_indicator":1,"id_subcategory":5010,"subcategory":"Personal uptake","visible_subcategory":1,"sub_sort_ord":1,"id_main_category":5000,"main_category":"General Digital Services","country":"DE","relevant":1,"existent":1,"val":62,"notes":"A survey found that 62% of the participants (1005 in Germany) were satisfied with the eGovernment services by their local authority. https:\/\/initiatived21.de\/app\/uploads\/2020\/10\/egovernment_monitor_2020_onlineausgabe.pdf","machine_readable":"No","upfreq":"Yearly","source":"https:\/\/initiatived21.de\/egovernment-monitor\/","last_update":"2020-12-31 00:00:00","rev_last":1}]}},"completeness":{"eID":{"Overall uptake":0.33,"Personal uptake":0.33,"Business uptake":0.5,"Public sector uptake":0.63,"Private sector support":1},"ePayment":{"Overall uptake":0,"Public sector uptake":0.4,"Private sector support":1},"Messaging":{"Overall uptake":0,"Personal uptake":0,"Business uptake":1,"Public sector uptake":0.13},"Transparency":{"Public sector uptake":0},"General Digital Services":{"Personal uptake":0.5}},"stuct":{"eID":["Overall uptake","Personal uptake","Business uptake","Public sector uptake","Private sector support"],"ePayment":["Overall uptake","Public sector uptake","Private sector support"],"Messaging":["Overall uptake","Personal uptake","Business uptake","Public sector uptake"],"Transparency":["Public sector uptake"],"General Digital Services":["Personal uptake"]},"facts":[{"statistic":"Number of businesses","val":"2,693,522"},{"statistic":"Population over 15 years old","val":"71,739,910"},{"statistic":"Total users","val":"74,433,432"},{"statistic":"Number of central\/federal government organisations","val":"106"},{"statistic":"Number of municipalities","val":"11,161"},{"statistic":"Number of other administrations","val":"294"},{"statistic":"Number of public and private service providers","val":"2,705,099"},{"statistic":"Number of public service providers (total)","val":"11,577"},{"statistic":"Number of regional public authorities","val":"16"}],"facts_year":2020,"rank_categories":{"eID":0.28,"ePayment":0.23,"Messaging":0.14,"Transparency":0,"General Digital Services":0.28},"timestamp":"2026-03-14T10:39:37+00:00"}